
Last Chance to Stop the Bank Spying Law
By Sean Haugh, LPNC Chair
A law that only the KGB could love -- the chilling,
so-called "Know Your Customer" proposal that would require
banks to spy on their customers -- is scheduled to go into
effect unless Americans can stop it by the March 8 deadline.
On that date, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation
(FDIC) will stop taking public comments about the Know Your
Customer regulation. Already, more than 50,000 people have
contacted the agency to oppose the proposal on
constitutional, privacy, or civil liberties grounds.
And no wonder. This regulation, published in the Federal
Register on December 7, 1998, requires banks to create a
profile of every customer and then notify the government if
they do anything "suspicious." Specifically, it requires
banks to determine their customer's sources of funds;
determine their customer's "normal and expected" transactions; identify transactions that are inconsistent
with expected patterns; and report suspicious activity to
federal investigators.
In other words, the government wants to turn every bank
teller into a government informer and everyone with a bank
account into a criminal suspect.
The government's rationale for imposing this regulation: To
catch money launderers. But how is monitoring everyone's
bank account to check for laundered money different from
searching everyone's home to check for stolen goods, or
stopping every car to check for drunk drivers?
It isn't, of course. In America, we're supposed to be
innocent until proven guilty -- not the other way around.
So what kind of "unusual activity" could set off a red flag
at your bank under Know Your Customer? Anything that
deviates from your normal pattern, like depositing a
Christmas bonus or inheritance, or withdrawing money to buy
a house or car. Soon, an ordinary trip to the bank could
turn into an interrogation, with Americans trying to prove
to agents from the FBI, the Internal Revenue Service, or
the Drug Enforcement Agency that they are not drug dealers
or money launderers.
In order to put the brakes on this Big Brother banking law,
the Libertarian Party has joined a coalition with the ACLU,
the California Bankers Association, the Free Congress
Foundation, and others to flood the FDIC with more comments
by the March 8 deadline. Unless it is stopped, the
regulation is scheduled to go into effect on April 1, 2000.
But stopping Know Your Customer won't be easy. Even after
being pummeled by 50,000 comments already -- 600 times as
many as the FDIC normally receives in response to a
proposed regulation -- the bureaucrats still haven't gotten
the message.
Now, they're suggesting that Know Your Customer simply
needs to be "reformed." Wrong. The last thing America
needs is a reformed bank spying law. Our message to the
FDIC is don't reform it; repeal it. Here's why:
- Americans' banking habits are none of the government's
business. In a free society, the government has no
business asking where innocent Americans get their money or
how they spend it. This is the kind of regulation one
might have expected in East Germany, North Korea, or Cuba.
But in the United States of America?
- It's an illegal, warrantless search that violates the
Fourth Amendment. This new rule would force banks to turn
over customers' records to government investigators within
48 hours -- without a search warrant. This is
unconstitutional, plain and simple.
- There is no money-laundering crisis in America. Of the
7,300 people charged with money laundering between 1987 and
1995, only 580 were convicted. So the government is
proposing to invade the banking privacy of over 100 million
Americans because of crimes committed by an average of 72
people a year.
- Know Your Customer could subject customers' money to
asset forfeiture. If customers can't immediately prove
they're not criminals, the government could seize their
money under asset forfeiture laws, which allow police to
impound the property of Americans without even charging
them with a crime. Perversely, instead of being the safest
place to store your money, banks could become the most
dangerous place.
If there's anything positive about the Know Your Customer
law, it's that it teaches Americans a lesson: Know Your
Government. In a supposedly free country, your government
is plotting to destroy your financial privacy and force
your bank to spy on you, with no evidence that you've done
anything wrong.
Now that's a crime. And we have until March 8 to prevent
it.
Here's how: Visit the website,
http://www.DefendYourPrivacy.com/
to sign
an electronic petition against the Know Your Customer law, and to send a
comment to the FDIC.
|